deviant art

Deviant Login Shop
 Join deviantART for FREE Take the Tour
×

More from ^Aeirmid in News


×
Hello, dA!

As you may be aware, we are in the process of revisiting gallery descriptions and making sure that all of our submissions categories make sense and are useful to you. We also want to make sure that categories are mutually exclusive so that people don't submit their deviations to the wrong galleries/categories by mistake. 

This process brought out a very interesting conversation among some members of the CV team. Specifically, we started talking about what, fundamentally, the difference between digital drawing and digital painting was. Does it depend on brush strokes? Is there some technique used on one but not the other? What sets the two apart?

 . . . OR, are they essentially the same thing? :XD:

Here's what the submission guidelines currently say about digital drawing and digital painting:

Digital Drawing: Digital art drawings created using computer-aided drawing tools or digital techniques.
Digital Painting: Digital art using digital painting & airbrushing techniques.

. . . not helpful, right?


What are your thoughts?


We're talking to all of you hard-core digital artists out there now. How do YOU see this discussion? Is there REALLY a difference between digital drawing and digital painting? If so, what is it? You can respond to this blog, of course, but you can also respond to our poll here.

Thanks guys! dA rocks. :dalove:


5,826

30 155 0

Details

Stats

Submitted on
September 18, 2012
Submitted with
Sta.sh Writer
Views
5,826
Favourites
30 (who?)
Comments
155
URL
Thumb
Only verified accounts can report policy violations. Please check your email and click on the verification link.
* Required field
Add a Comment:
 
:icontamarar:
*tamaraR Sep 27, 2012   Digital Artist
Sometimes it's clear to me but other times it isn't. Is a drawing one with lines and a digital painting without? I'm not always sure. I think it would be better if it became one option.
Reply
:iconshink0u-chan:
~Shink0u-chan Sep 21, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
same thing...there are many who use tablets for digital paintings...i thought the definition for the two would be different.
Reply
:iconelixia-dragmire:
=Elixia-Dragmire Sep 21, 2012  Professional Digital Artist
oooooooook, gonna say this.

But when I submit a piece to a group as Digi Painting, it'll get rejected BUT if its digi drawing its not ... go figure?

Now a drawing i consider it as something that uses a dry media, pencil, pen, charcoal etc and a painting is something that uses a wet media, acrlyics, oils, watercolours.

now digitally this makes no sense!

I also lean towards Digi drawing primarliy because my images look static, whereas some digi paintings can look fliud. its a tedious link at best.

I think many devaints think of the catagories as tiered, such as digital pianting is better than digital drawing but that an assumation of mine.
Reply
:iconstygma:
=Stygma Sep 20, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
I am always confused about that! The problem is rarely use only one technic in a digital artwork. It's both drawing and painting. So, where should I put it? I'm trying to guess how much of painting vs drawing is shown to decide in wich category I will put the art.
Reply
:iconssceles:
~ssceles Sep 20, 2012  Hobbyist Digital Artist
I already posted but as a follow-up:

I got told because "half" of my piece was line art, that it was a drawing. I don't consider one hour of lineart to be "half" my piece when I spend four hours painting afterward. The time it takes to draw typically takes up a fourth of my piece, more or less. I use watercolor, airbrush, and marker tools in SAI and I do not merely cell-shade. When I worked traditionally with watercolors, I'd ink it when I was done I was still praised for my painting ability.

Talk about mixed mediums. If could just stop at 'digital art' without having to choose drawing or painting I would.

But if its suddenly a painting instead of a drawing when I remove the lineart layer, when its the same coloring technique no matter what, that's just silly.
Reply
:iconthiaminatenn:
*ThiaminaTenn Sep 20, 2012   Digital Artist
For me, drawing means to use pencils for creating lines, hatchings, sketches (ok that's hard because you can also sketch with brushes >.< but I think most people sketch their character or whatever with a pencil in to their sketchbook's...)

And painting means (for me) to use brushes, playing around with colors, colorblending or even rough brushstrokes but not to create line for line, even though styles can change from hard to very smooth. (for example a landscape created with oils is obviously a painting and when you create something similar digitally you would also call it painting in my opinion)

But I think for many people it's both kinda the same - digital and tradtional :D
And sometimes it could be really hard to choose, because some people mix it strongly.
Reply
:iconbrightwolf1:
Mood: Stuck =BrightWolf1 Sep 20, 2012  Student General Artist
I always thought they were the same thing O_O in fact, Since I upload a lot of Digital art over paper drawn.
Reply
:iconmel-mel:
~mel-mel Sep 20, 2012  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Digital drawing I usually think like lineart or cell shading. Digital painting makes me think like a painting, but done on computer.
Reply
:icondeidaraart5:
In my opinion digital painting is layering up colors slowly to make smoother transitions (not necessarily realistically, but not cell shadig either). Digital paintings can have lineart, or be lineless, as it's the coloring itself that is the painting part. Digital drawing is more hard shading, no shading, lineart, or sketches.
Reply
:iconpedigri:
~Pedigri Nov 13, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
I thought the same thing about digital drawing.
Reply
Add a Comment: